Dr. Jastreboff on the Reasons for Failure in TRT ...

[beemovie]

From the year 1905: "Dr. Guy Clifford Powell has perfected a system of treatment that actually cures, as we know from its results. It is known us the Electro-Vibratory apparatus for the cure of deafness and head noises,"

http://www.nolindan.com/lindancollection/ql208.html

 

[Sen]

What in the world is "really, really weird" about emotion and despair?

The manner in which Dr. Jastreboff chose to express it.

I also see that you are now choosing to ignore Jastreboff's apparent dishonesty about Jason Diemilio.

 

[Michael2013]

Dr. Jastreboff told me that he never ever suggested to the individual that his ear pain would get better if his depression improved, even though that is what the individual related in the chat. He said very possibly the notion might have come from another of the gentleman's doctors and he got confused, but it definitely didn't come from Dr. Jastreboff.

I'll be the first to say that we can't know what Jastreboff actually said based on that chat transcript, but I have to also say I am somewhat surprised to see his response was to flat out deny it altogether. I was expecting he would clarify what he actually said, rather than deny it completely or put it off on another Dr.

There was a mention in this thread of Jason Diemilio, so I did a quick search and found this post by Rob which also talks about his experience with Jastreboff: "TRT did not change the fact that he was still extremely sound-sensitive. Dr. Jastreboff felt that this was due to Jason's other health challenges -- which may have been neurologically based."

That seems to be two people saying the same thing, is it not?

-Mike

 

[Michael2013]

Besides TRT I also blame the industry which specialises in selling solutions related to hearing in specific, e.g. noise amplification devices (hearing aids), cochlear implants are some of the biggest beneficiaries right now.
Do you think these cooperations are playing an active role in inhibiting the progress and advances in the field? hair cell regeneration in the cochlear? In an effort to maintain profits etc.........................Yes I do.

I don't. Otherwise they wouldn't be funding things like this:

http://news.yahoo.com/experimental-cochlear-implant-treatment-could-improve-hearing-182249164.html

"In experiments on deaf guinea pigs, researchers found that the new technique, which uses cochlear implants to deliver DNA directly to the nerves, restored the animals' hearing to a near-normal level, according to the report, published today (April 23) in the journal Science Translational Medicine. Cochlear implants are electronic devices that can be surgically implanted to restore hearing in people whose deafness is caused by certain conditions.

If proven effective in humans, this experimental use of a cochlear implant to fix the nerves could offer significant improvement over current implants, the researchers said. For one, it could allow patients to hear and music."

-Mike

 

[jss]

@Dr Nagler,
you are highly educated man and I'm in disbelief that you either can't or don't want to understand what these people are saying.

TRT, CBT, Neuromonics.....is soooooo yestrday!

Dr Nagler we need your help to start pushing things forward, we are still stuck in the same mud as from the times of Van Gogh and Beethoven.

People SUFER! We need relief not habituation therapies!

I said it once and will say it again, the person of your reputation and influence could do so so much more, donating to ATA is a waste of your money, the cure is not coming from there, please help us being heard!

Let's all together come up with something smart that will rise the awareness and the urgency of the situation.

Amen valeri..

In my opinion TRT stands in the way of "real" progress... it has for years. This is 2014 We are looking for some significant noise reduction not learning to accept tinnitus as your friend. I truly hope Autifony, Otonomy and Auris Medical bury TRT someday or at least give us some options.

 

[valeri]

@jss
Agree, but not only TRT!
Neuromonics, CBT, mindfulnes....
None of these therapies is a solution, it's a bandaid!
I'm not saying that cbt or meditation is not beneficial in some areas of health, but when it comes to tinnitus we need a relief not somebody telling us to change the way we think.
And at the end of the day it all comes down to money, audiology is a biiiiiiig business, lot of money to lose, but with all my heart I hope they all go bankrupt