Because keppra is a safe drug compared to trobalt. Also keppra inhabits KV3.1 channels, doesn't open them. Trobalt worked because it opens channels, keppra doesn't
Xexus Danny...you are still saying this???!!! Where did you get this piece of info???
Ref. Keppra and basics, including zero evidence that it works on Kv3 channels see this post in other Keppra thread:
https://www.tinnitustalk.com/thread...d-for-my-hyperacusis.8946/page-23#post-146596
And from that:
Note: For the non 'research oriented' but interested in Keppra, you may want to just skip down to the "key take-aways" in part 2. of this post...as yes, I do tend to drone on. Not changing my 'spots' now, sorry.
@svintegrity ...Ta much for add on info. post as indeed backs up the stuff I seem to be finding as dig deeper. Also much thanks to @111 down under, for two excellent tomes on Keppra (and Brivaracetam) which for the die-hards will get the 'links' below.
1. ~ OK...so for all you could ever want to know about Keppra (& Briv.) here is a link from a more than exhaustive study out of Germany in 2012. And don't get put off by it being in German to start with as the main text is in English. However,do be put off with the fact that it is 170 pages long before the 'references' start!!!
http://hss.ulb.uni-bonn.de/2012/3068/3068.pdf
I did not review it all. No way! However I did skim, and also looked for (search/find) key things of interest to me re. my whole initial approach to taking Keppra...that it was a Kv3.1 drug, like Autifony's famous star - or at least that Keppra had strong elements of Kv3.1 possible modulation.
Short answer...There is absolutely zero back-up or mention of that in this German paper. There is small reference to generalized Potassium channels within epileptic MOA ideas...and yes, in relation to our old comrade in arms (or hell, perhaps to some), Retigabine.
Conclusion on all that, to me OK, is that Keppra is not a Kv drug of any significance.
Thus I am no longer thinking of it in those terms, and no longer acting on it in those terms. Results, are as prior stated...I'm dropping off and not heading for 'break the doors down' dose effective inter-extra cellular neuronal saturation levels. *[And yes, Keppra is considered 'dose linear' but I consider that more relevant for the epilepsy modelnot the 'model' I had in mind. Also the Australian TGA paper next makes me wonder a bit WTF is going on with "dose" anyhow...or my concentration perhaps!].
2. ~ OK...the second paper, c/o the Australian TGA (which does some good work indeed...as per our research efforts on Retigabine, etc., etc.). This one is shorter and more readable, with some easier 'take-aways' that could be of interest to some here considering Keppra, or already taking it. *[And yes, I need to re-read it again (and maybe again!) to see what the hell is going on re the different "studies" quoted. That there is hardly any difference between doses of 1,ooo mg total v. 3,000 mg total, and that maybe Europeans act in a hugely different manner to Americans at even lower dose differentials???!!! Ummmmmmmm...must be me! Though the issue could just be that these 'problems' are all within the "Add-on AED Therapy" department, where more than just one AED...than just Keppra, is involved!. Plus they do not indicate which prior AEDs were actually used...So this could all be a red herring for us anyhow].
http://www.medicines.org.au/files/txplevet.pdf
Key take-aways, summarized in short (thus incomplete) sound bytes:
- Due to its complete and linear absorption, plasma levels can be predicted from the oral dose of levetiracetam expressed as mg/kg bodyweight. Therefore, there is no need for plasma level monitoring of levetiracetam.
Translate as: Body weight and size matter! (Also noted c/o @svintegrity).
- Following single dose administration (20 mg/kg) to epileptic children (6 to 12 years of age), the half-life of levetiracetam was 6.0 +/- 1.1 hours. The apparent body clearance was approximately 30% higher than in epileptic adults.
Translate as: Yeah you younger folks with less 'wear and tear' on your body parts are likely to unload Keppra faster and better than us more 'matured' (screwed over by various sundry health insults) folks.
- Monotherapy (i.e. = just Keppra, no other AED add-ons)...The recommended starting dose is 250 mg twice daily which should be increased to an initial therapeutic dose of 500 mg twice daily after two weeks. The dose can be further increased by 250 mg twice daily very two weeks depending upon the clinical response. The maximum dose is 1,500 mg twice daily.
Translate as: The Aussies seem to believe in classic titration - both in and out of Keppra use. Mmmmmmm...
- Overdosage: The highest known dose of levetiracetam received in the clinical development program was 6,000 mg/day. Other than drowsiness, there were no adverse events in the few known cases of overdose in clinical trials.
Translate as: Go wild! Compared to Trobalt, "Twinkies" may be more harmful to your health than this stuff. Well, as usual, not everyone is created equally and treat accordingly.
Ummmm... OK think that's about it for my Keppra 101. Now just observation and reflection...Wunderbar! Or possibly..."Shit, that is a bit of egg in the face!" could be more appropriate, depending on your disposition.
Best, Zimichael
@Zimichael : my line of thinking is that if you swallow the various pills out there which may have impact on the various Kv-channels - all at once (and just once) - then I am pretty sure the person's tinnitus would go away...Thus the words "may be" are more suitable than "is" or "does"...in my layman's scientific, but very thoroughly covered research on Keppra, and talking to some Kv researchers about it's MOA.
@Zimichael : my line of thinking is that if you swallow the various pills out there which may have impact on the various Kv-channels - all at once (and just once) - then I am pretty sure the person's tinnitus would go away...
(Source)Anti-seizure drugs (for example gabapentin, topiramate, levetiracetam) may be effective in persons with hyperacusis due to irritable neural pathways. These may be working on similar circuitry as is helpful for migraine. Generally speaking, seizure medications that work for migraine are also mood stabilizers, so they may also be helpful there.
Are you going to discuss this further with a provider? Being that reactivity is my debilitation factor, something like this is like dangling a possible amazing carrot in front of me, however I worry about side effects and the coming off of it eventually and what possible hell that could be. It would be even more helpful to know a general timeline for Dr. Shore's device. If its not available in the USA 4-6 months from now, that would further make me consider something like this more. It's crazy to read @Viking's post and a few others who basically reported reactivity/hyperacusis just vanished.→ Effect of Antiepileptic Drug Levetiracetam on Cochlear Function
"Audiogenic seizures."
Maybe why some with reactive tinnitus get relief. I think 4-5 benefitted here.
Levetiracetam is also mentioned here for hyperacusis caused by irritable neural pathways:
(Source)
Levetiracetam could be worth a look!
I suspect reactive tinnitus and noxacusis to share the same mechanism. I wanted to get on Keppra but was denied (for now). I will attach the full article here for anyone interested. Maybe I'll find the time to read it in the near future.Are you going to discuss this further with a provider? Being that reactivity is my debilitation factor, something like this is like dangling a possible amazing carrot in front of me, however I worry about side effects and the coming off of it eventually and what possible hell that could be. It would be even more helpful to know a general timeline for Dr. Shore's device. If its not available in the USA 4-6 months from now, that would further make me consider something like this more. It's crazy to read @Viking's post and a few others who basically reported reactivity/hyperacusis just vanished.
Thank you for sharing that full text, @StoneInFocus. I will add it to my documents that I am taking with me on September 15th to my Neuro appointment. I have been waiting 5 months for this appointment and he is apparently a great doctor with compassion, so am hoping to get a script and see results! If I can calm my reactivity, I'm a functioning adult again.I suspect reactive tinnitus and noxacusis to share the same mechanism. I wanted to get on Keppra but was denied (for now). I will attach the full article here for anyone interested. Maybe I'll find the time to read it in the near future.
Very, very informative. Thank you for this.Keppra, and also Nifedipine, block the influx of calcium ions through L-type calcium channels.
Wow. Thank you so much for that information @StoneInFocus. That alone should get you a Keppra script, and it angers me to no end that you were denied it. I would go back or to another neurologist with all your info and demand to try it. I have been advised by my psychiatrist and 2 investigative pharmacists to ask the neurologist to try Keppra as they all feel, based on research, it could very well provide relief to my reactivity.I think I figured out the reason why Keppra works for some people with hyperacusis and reactive tinnitus. Apologies in advance if this has already been said before in this thread.
View attachment 55698
If I understood it correctly, in the synapses located at the basolateral membrane of outer hair cells (OHCs), electrical activity via the activation of voltage-gated L-type calcium channels causes releases of glutamate through vesicles into the boutons of type II afferents. We know that normally, "glutamatergic synaptic transmission from OHCs [to type II afferent boutons] is weak. Individual OHCs release single vesicles with low probability so that summed excitation from the entire pool [do not know what Fuchs means by entire pool] of presynaptic OHCs is required for action potential initiation. Maximal stimulation [?] of an OHC had a one in four chance of releasing a single vesicle during maximal stimulation. Each vesicle causes a 4-mV depolarization [of the type II afferent] on average, thus requiring 7 or more concurrent vesicles for the type II afferent to reach the 25-mV threshold for action potential initiation."
But here's the curious thing. Paul Fuchs found out that the number and size of OHC synaptic ribbons increased after mice were exposed to damaging sound. Using a statistical model Paul Fuchs estimated that a global 20 % increase in OHC ribbon count observed in the noise-exposed mice is estimated to cause a 99 % increase in action potentials [of type II afferent neurons] in response to maximal stimulation of OHCs across the entire population of 1000 (virtual) type II afferents.
In short, if I understood it correctly, acoustic stimulation --> L-type calcium channels open --> calcium ions enter the outer hair cell --> OHC depolarizes --> glutamate is sent to type II afferents --> Type II afferents depolarize.
Now, in the case of acoustic damage, because of increased ribbon number and size, the same OHC depolarization makes it more likely for a type II neuron to fire. So that is a possible reason why normally non-painful sounds become painful to people with hearing damage.
Keppra, and also Nifedipine, block the influx of calcium ions through L-type calcium channels. So theoretically it should alleviate hearing disorders where type II neurons are the culprit, as is the case with noxacusis and maybe (reactive) tinnitus as well.
Interesting. What makes you believe that?I suspect reactive tinnitus and noxacusis to share the same mechanism.
I initially had an appointment with my doctor this Monday, but we had to reschedule to next week. In the previous week I have sent him some articles, including the one about ribbon count and size after acoustic damage I attached here. I am hoping the doctor has read the articles and I can make a good case for Keppra, or maybe even a Nifedipine prescription now.Wow. Thank you so much for that information @StoneInFocus. That alone should get you a Keppra script, and it angers me to no end that you were denied it. I would go back or to another neurologist with all your info and demand to try it. I have been advised by my psychiatrist and 2 investigative pharmacists to ask the neurologist to try Keppra as they all feel, based on research, it could very well provide relief to my reactivity.
Best of luck with your appointment, looking forward to hear from you and I hope Keppra provides you good relief.My appointment is next Friday the 15th. I will update here if I get a script, and I am going to be asking for brand name if insurance will cover it.
It's really interesting that a psychiatrist and these investigative pharmacists advised you to ask for Keppra. Did they provide you with any articles? Why couldn't the psychiatrist prescribe you Keppra in this case?Wow. Thank you so much for that information @StoneInFocus. That alone should get you a Keppra script, and it angers me to no end that you were denied it. I would go back or to another neurologist with all your info and demand to try it. I have been advised by my psychiatrist and 2 investigative pharmacists to ask the neurologist to try Keppra as they all feel, based on research, it could very well provide relief to my reactivity.
Wow, your doctor said Keppra is a new drug?Unfortunately I could not get a prescription for Keppra. The doctor said Keppra was 'expensive', a new drug and he had not really prescribed it for his patients before I believe. The doctor told me to try Pregabalin or Carbamazepine for two weeks, I opted for the latter.
I asked him if Keppra or Ivabradine are on the table if these two drugs were to fail,
but I could not get a clear yes or no out of him.
I am not really sure to what extent the doctor had read my articles, but it seemed like the article about the HCN2 channel and tinnitus caught his attention.
The doctor told me to stop the 0.5 mg Clonazepam without tapering off.
Considering the safety of Keppra and Carbamazepine, I considered the former to be the safest of the two. I am really spooked about the potential side effects of the latter.
It's really interesting that a psychiatrist and these investigative pharmacists advised you to ask for Keppra. Did they provide you with any articles? Why couldn't the psychiatrist prescribe you Keppra in this case?
I do not know where you have done your research, but after reading a lot of user reviews on drugs.com, I´ve come to the totally opposite conclusion. Actually, I don´t think I´ve ever read such many horrifying reviews on a drug as I have with Keppra.Considering the safety of Keppra and Carbamazepine, I considered the former to be the safest of the two. I am really spooked about the potential side effects of the latter.
Carbamazepine scares me because, according to Wikipedia, it is a possible serotonin reuptake inhibitor. Carbamazepine might also be ototoxic.I do not know where you have done your research, but after reading a lot of user reviews on drugs.com, I´ve come to the totally opposite conclusion. Actually, I don´t think I´ve ever read such many horrifying reviews on a drug as I have with Keppra.
"Of the 99 [trigeminal neuralgia] patients who had a good initial response [to carbamazepine, CBZ], 19 developed late resistance in that the pain recurred and did not then respond to CBZ. In these cases, resistance developed 2 months to 10 years (mean 4 years) after commencing treatment."As I´ve said before, it´s also such a strong inducer of the CYP 3A4 enzyme, that not only will it affect the metabolism of other drugs, it kind of trips its own foot as well ("auto induction"). After 2-3 weeks on the drug, the serum concentration of the drug will decrease by ⅔ and you will have to up dose to remain a "steady state". It has a really long half-life though.This is from what I have read and understood. I might be wrong.
As you know, it helped me with my tinnitus and noxacusis more than any drug I´ve ever tried (over a short span) and I am sure it will help you as well, but I really question its viability.
I have been on SSRI for 25 years. Nothing to be scared of.Carbamazepine scares me because, according to Wikipedia, it is a possible serotonin reuptake inhibitor. Carbamazepine might also be ototoxic.
I have never read anything about Keppra causing adverse effects that last permanently, unlike Carbamazepine or SSRIs.
"Of the 99 [trigeminal neuralgia] patients who had a good initial response [to carbamazepine, CBZ], 19 developed late resistance in that the pain recurred and did not then respond to CBZ. In these cases, resistance developed 2 months to 10 years (mean 4 years) after commencing treatment."
I'm not too worried about developing tolerance for now. My first objective is to find something that can alleviate the pain at all, and then subsequently translate that to a long-term treatment strategy.
The doctor told me to take Carbamazepine 100 mg two times per day for two weeks. I've started yesterday. Maybe I'll ask the clinic if I can take a higher dose next week if I don't suffer from any serious side effects the following days nor notice much effect on my noxacusis.
How is your benzo withdrawal doing?
Yes, I've heard about that phenomenon as well. As I'm already prone to anger outbursts I can only imagine the terror I'm going to inflict on this forum when on Keppra Luckily I'm on Carbamazepine then.There is something called "Keppra Rage".
I wish you the best man. Hoping you find the strength to ride it out.Benzo withdrawal is killing me.
If you make one, I'll post a nice comment there If I have good results from the Carbamazepine, I'll make a separate thread for that in the hyperacusis subforum.Maybe we should start a new thread called "Tinnitus, Noxacusis and Anti-Epileptics"
Well done @ErikaS.My neurologist had no issue writing me a script for Keppra. I'm picking it up this afternoon, and I will start with the first dose tonight. I'm starting on a low dose, 250 mg twice a day, and will up it in a week or so.
Now, just praying with all of me that it actually works against my reactivity.
That's so exciting! Please let us know how it goes!My neurologist had no issue writing me a script for Keppra. I'm picking it up this afternoon, and I will start with the first dose tonight. I'm starting on a low dose, 250 mg twice a day, and will up it in a week or so.
Now, just praying with all of me that it actually works against my reactivity.
I hope it goes well for you @ErikaS - I have my fingers crossed!My neurologist had no issue writing me a script for Keppra. I'm picking it up this afternoon, and I will start with the first dose tonight. I'm starting on a low dose, 250 mg twice a day, and will up it in a week or so.
Now, just praying with all of me that it actually works against my reactivity.
Thank you! I will definitely share updates.That's so exciting! Please let us know how it goes!
You have reactive tinnitus, eh? Any signs of loudness hyperacusis or noxacusis?