- Aug 29, 2015
- 7,069
- Tinnitus Since
- 2004
- Cause of Tinnitus
- Meniere's Disease
Also the BTA may seem a bit faceless at times
Yes, that's me, and thank you!
We are trying to make this happenOh it would be nice to have a little video done to share with us way over yonder...
Would it be feasible, if appropriate, for Tinnitus Hub to place a small donation/charity box for coins and small bills on their table at the BTA Expo? The donations would go for support of tinnitus research in memory of Daniel - I'm assuming whatever is collected could somehow be added to the GoFundMe account. The BTA Conference precedes the Expo so perhaps Tinnitus Hub could do the same there, if they are attending.
There will be. The latest agenda and information is here; https://www.tinnitus.org.uk/Event/talkingtinnitus
We've got some strong keynote speakers on this.
Sorry to hear you feel that way. We're looking to show research that has led to a therapy/device, etc currently available now. Open to suggestions of any we should include in this or future events?Have just read the list of speakers and pretty disappointing. Little new research
We've funded two projects with UCL, where Dr McKenna is the lead applicant. Full details here;Laurence McKenna popping up yet again - this man must have taken so many thousands from the small pot of funds BTA has over the years (money which could have gone to original research).
This is available on the NHS, via the Royal National Throat Nose and Ear Hospital, Grays Inn Road, London.to support his Mindfulness therapy practice.
Full Randomised Control Trial study paper, assessing mindfulness based CBT - including an active placebo is available to read here;Not once in these studies has his approach ever been tested against placebo.
We've invited companies so people can look at and evaluate what's available in a safe and supportive environment. If people don't want to look around the exhibition or interact with people on the stands, they don't have to.all the commercial companies BTA has invited - who all want the desperate tinnitus sufferers' money.
We're happy they'll be there too!I'm glad that at least the Tinnitus Hub is offering some objective non-profit advice
Actually yes.Sorry to hear you feel that way. . Open to suggestions of any we should include in this or future events?
And no doubt available privately as well. Maybe you can tell us how much Dr Mckenna charges for his "therapy" rubber-stamped by the BTA at considerable cost to its limited research funds?We've funded two projects with UCL, where Dr McKenna is the lead applicant. This is available on the NHS, via the Royal National Throat Nose and Ear Hospital, Grays Inn Road, London.
This wasn't a proper placebo tested trial - ie no use of a little white tablet which the therapist tells the patient will improve their tinnitus was issued. Instead apparently some relaxation techniques were used - no doubt designed to be so rubbish that anything else was seen as preferable. When Lawrence Mckenna does an actual placebo trial - with little white tablet as placebo (ie the internationally recognised placebo effect) do let us know!Full Randomised Control Trial study paper, assessing mindfulness based CBT - including an active placebo is available to read here;
How nice of you! Did these companies pay anything for the privilege of getting commercial access to some vulnerable tinnitus patients. If so how much and who to?We've invited companies so people can look at and evaluate what's available in a safe and supportive environment.
I'm assuming these aren't available for presentation if the suggestion is to trial these? We're only looking to present research at the conference that has concluded.A study of the use of HBOT for patients with acute tinnitus and hearing loss (less than 6 months).
A study of the use of Clonazepam for patients with chronic tinnitus.
Each one to be placebo tested.
I've no idea how much Dr McKenna charges or if he does. It is not rubber-stamped by the BTA. Nor is any other research we fund, and like everyone else we await definitive proof of any treatment. The results of this trial need replicating by other groups to verify and ideally evaluated in an independent systematic review.And no doubt available privately as well. Maybe you can tell us how much Dr Mckenna charges for his "therapy" rubber-stamped by the BTA at considerable cost to its limited research funds?
I do recommend you read the paper, the relaxation group also improved significantly. It was a valid and active placebo.This wasn't a proper placebo tested trial - ie no use of a little white tablet which the therapist tells the patient will improve their tinnitus was issued. Instead apparently some relaxation techniques were used - no doubt designed to be so rubbish that anything else was seen as preferable. When Lawrence Mckenna does an actual placebo trial - with little white tablet as placebo (ie the internationally recognised placebo effect) do let us know!
They do - we wouldn't be able to afford to put on the day otherwise. The amount is commercially sensitive, so won't be published. BTA staff will be around and will support people with independent information, as will Tinnitus Hub I'm sure. We will also have information for people about how to access free support either through the NHS in their area or via the BTA. We really want to give people the ability to understand all of the options available and be able to then make an informed choice about what they want to try, if anything.Did these companies pay anything for the privilege of getting commercial access to some vulnerable tinnitus patients. If so how much and who to?
No these are two important potential treatments which the BTA has given absolutely no money for research. Instead it has given Lawrence Mckenna money time and again to perform the same research.And maybe you would like to repeat your assertion that the BTA has only funded research by Dr Mckenna twice? (as records suggest differently.)I'm assuming these aren't available for presentation if the suggestion is to trial these?
Well that's quite easily solved - you can ask him the question. After all if you are funding his research over and over again that sort of due diligence should be automatic.I've no idea how much Dr McKenna charges or if he does.
I did which is how I know that a real placebo - the little white pill - wasn't used.I do recommend you read the paper
Tinnitus is NOT a psychological condition - anyone indicating that it is has no place being the head of a tinnitus charity.Little white pills,' are not valid in psychology trials.
Again very easily solved. Offer a clinical trial offering treatment for tinnitus but don't give any more information than that. The real reason that no "little white pill" placebo test for mindfulness tinnitus trials has ever been given is that the mindfulness results would perform so badly in comparison to placebo.If you signed up for a trial into 'mindfulness' and were given a little white pill, you'd know you were in the placebo group
Well how very convenient. Actually it would be much, much better if you were open and transparent about this. Then the tinnitus patients attending this day would be in a much better position to know exactly how much each company was paying to gain access to them.The amount is commercially sensitive, so won't be published
To my knowledge the BTA has never received an application to investigate either of these. We ask for applications but can only assess the applications we receive.No these are two important potential treatments which the BTA has given absolutely no money for research.
I didn't. I was trying to make the point that the trial was assessing a psychological intervention. Apologies for not being clearer.Tinnitus is NOT a psychological condition - anyone indicating that it is has no place being the head of a tinnitus charity.
You're making me doubt this now! Pretty sure it's 2. Which other ones are there? We've funded research to verify (or otherwise) the model of tinnitus Dr McKenna developed, this was a study via the University of Nottingham though, not with Dr McKenna.And maybe you would like to repeat your assertion that the BTA has only funded research by Dr Mckenna twice? (as records suggest differently.)
We have been transparent that companies are paying to exhibit, and one is a sponsor. There's no way to do the expo on this scale without them. There's no need for people to visit the exhibition - it's only one part of the expo - and if people are overly concerned there's no compulsion to attend.Well how very convenient. Actually it would be much, much better if you were open and transparent about this.
Little white pills,' are not valid in psychology trials.
I agree. The research seems to suggest that many of these therapies help all groups and people with severe tinnitus moreso than other groups. BUT the success stories aren't out there for the severe groups, which provides a contradiction. Lots of hypotheses as to why this is.for those with more severe tinnitus there's not many success stories.
I think 2 points have been conflated. 1. Pills as a placebo for a psychology treatment isn't particularly valid. 2. We do support drugs trials, as and when they ask for support or when we find and come into contact with them. We have supported or have relationships with many of the companies active in the UK. Not so much those solely in the USA or elsewhere. We'd love to but probably aren't much use to them currently. It's something we're looking to do more of. What I would say from discussions I've had with pharma companies in tinnitus and associated fields is they do understand tinnitus, understand the challenges and are searching for opportunities.Why not support and encourage these drug companies for a tinnitus drug.
Tinnitus is NOT a psychological condition
As for us poor people with severe tinnitus (myself included) perhaps a good way to represent us in this expo or the next one is to simply tell our story. I'm sure that if asked, myself and a few other people who are affected by our severe tinnitus would love to pen up a short (and RESPECTFUL) snippet about our tinnitus and our experiences for someone to read. We don't have to have a whole panel devoted to us to make an impact. I know when I told my "success" story on here it had a profound impact on various levels for many members here.
I don't think they'll help to make people understand how horrible tinnitus can be.
They do - we wouldn't be able to afford to put on the day otherwise. The amount is commercially sensitive, so won't be published. BTA staff will be around and will support people with independent information, as will Tinnitus Hub I'm sure. We will also have information for people about how to access free support either through the NHS in their area or via the BTA. We really want to give people the ability to understand all of the options available and be able to then make an informed choice about what they want to try, if anything.
In order to help people make an informed choice, there could be a talk to educate about what to look out for when choosing a tinnitus product and especially how to evaluate the support for claims being made about a product or procedure. Maybe too late for this expo, but maybe more important when considering supplements, etc sold over the internet. Maybe something in print? -TC
As for us poor people with severe tinnitus (myself included) perhaps a good way to represent us in this expo or the next one is to simply tell our story.
We've funded research to verify (or otherwise) the model of tinnitus Dr McKenna developed, this was a study via the University of Nottingham though, not with Dr McKenna.
As for us poor people with severe tinnitus (myself included) perhaps a good way to represent us in this expo or the next one is to simply tell our story.
This will be part of the expo, we also include stories like this in our magazine Quiet, (as does ATA in Tinnitus Today). It's the most valued part of our magazine by readers. We also use stories like this as 'case studies,' for the media (assuming people are willing to discuss their tinnitus on radio, TV, press, etc.), particularly when we have an awareness campaign or for Tinnitus Week. Noticed you're in the US, if you reached out to the ATA sure they'd be interested in highlighting your case.
Has the Nottingham study been published? - TC