It's not my view it's a fact.
Telling people the ridiculous lie that loudness level doesn't equal distress level makes it seem like a viable treatment is pseudo scientific hypnosis and diminishes the urgency to develop an actual cure. This is something I and many others have understood long before you even had tinnitus.Personal opinion will not cure any disease.
It's impossible to do that. Nearly every single human being has some type of psychological condition. And if you have tinnitus, you are guaranteed to have some condition because it drives you mad. You can always blame psyche for tinnitus distress. There's always a way to blame it.A fact with respect to your question would be is a testimony of a patient with a high tinnitus loudness that is unable to adapt to the tinnitus and that has demonstrably no relation to any psychological condition that I cited above.
When people like @ajc and I, who are polar opposites on most things agree on something, take heed.You might want to give ATA a pass.
Their board chair thinks tinnitus is not a big deal and for most people it just fades away. The ATA are the scum of the earth.
https://www.tinnitustalk.com/thread...-is-this-the-right-message-to-send-out.32191/
Your statement is not a fact. A fact with respect to your question would be is a testimony of a patient with a high tinnitus loudness that is unable to adapt to the tinnitus and that has demonstrably no relation to any psychological condition that I cited above. This patient or group of patients could be established as fact. I would be happy to see a study or even a single case. Otherwise, it doesn't help us any further and is nothing more than personal opinion. Personal opinion will not cure any disease.
I wear earplugs on the streets
This.@dan Since the beginning of 2018. If I knew it wouldn't get any louder I would 100% take it. But that's not a given it seems...
Based on what? Sounds like nonsense.Hey,
did you just recently get tinnitus?
I think the masking should be adjusted to the loudness of the tinnitus. When I first got tinnitus (without hearing loss) it was extremely loud as well but it became quieter after some weeks. Partly this is also due to my better understanding of why some people react to the tinnitus and some others do not although their tinnitus may be loud as well. In the beginning the masking was relatively high because the noise was unbearable for me but I followed the instructions that I found in the book "Tinnitus Retraining Therapy" and tried to mask the tinnitus only partially.
Now, I cannot say with certainty that the noise went away because my brain habituated because I suspect that I have some sort of somatosensory tinnitus that may be related to some real physiological malfunction in the region of the ear and the neck. So it may well be that the noise became quieter because the situation in that region improved.
As far as I know there is no relation between the loudness of tinnitus and the ability to adapt to it, i.e. no matter how loud it is you can get used to it and your brain after some time starts to shift the signal out of your consciousness.**********
Also: Can you modulate your tinnitus by neck movements or by moving your chin?
They are evil in their obtuseness. Organizations like the ATA and BTA, because of their level of prominence and visibility, are actually our greatest enemies.To ajc:
Thanks very much for posting that thread.
I had no idea ATA could be so willfully obtuse.
However, the statistics concerning the pervasiveness and severity of this cannot be gainsaid.
One ENT Doctor told me that this will become an epidemic condition for the retiring Baby Boom Generation.
I recall that when I mentioned Desyncra's cost to someone I know who is 67, he said "Are you kidding? I would
gladly pay $20,000.00 to alleviate this infernal condition."
Some people who claim that they have loud tinnitus insist they are used to it. But, we have no way of knowing because we can't hear it. Only they can.Look there bud.
Certain things are really just common sense.
If you touch a hot stove, you will get burned.
You don't need to put together a study group for that one.
Same with tinnitus volume.
Unless you are not human, louder tinnitus means more distress.
It's really that simple.
The only difference between tinnitus and no tinnitus is really the volume.
You will never hear a person with no tinnitus to complain about tinnitus, because they simply cannot hear it (think of that as the volume button turned all the way down).
Now let's crank up that button all the way up and see if anyone notices (I think you know the answer to that one).
By now you had probably realized, that the only difference between the person who will not complain about tinnitus and the person that will, is the position of the volume button.
If you are still not convinced, maybe you can put your ear right onto my guitar amplifier, as I steadily increase the volume... see how far you can make it, before volume becomes a factor for you.
Again, you do not need a double blind fucking study for this kind of basic, common knowledge stuff.
Telling people the ridiculous lie that loudness level doesn't equal distress level makes it seem like a viable treatment is pseudo scientific hypnosis and diminishes the urgency to develop an actual cure. This is something I and many others have understood long before you even had tinnitus.
Stop telling lies.
It's impossible to do that. Nearly every single human being has some type of psychological condition. And if you have tinnitus, you are guaranteed to have some condition because it drives you mad. You can always blame psyche for tinnitus distress. There's always a way to blame it.
Does that mean you should blame psyche? No it doesn't. Tinnitus loudness matters. If you don't believe it does, bring your ass over here and I'll make your tinnitus three times louder, let's see what you say then.
Where did you even come from? Joined today and started preaching this rubbish?
Look there bud.
Certain things are really just common sense.
If you touch a hot stove, you will get burned.
You don't need to put together a study group for that one.
Same with tinnitus volume.
Unless you are not human, louder tinnitus means more distress.
It's really that simple.
The only difference between tinnitus and no tinnitus is really the volume.
You will never hear a person with no tinnitus to complain about tinnitus, because they simply cannot hear it (think of that as the volume button turned all the way down).
Now let's crank up that button all the way up and see if anyone notices (I think you know the answer to that one).
By now you had probably realized, that the only difference between the person who will not complain about tinnitus and the person that will, is the position of the volume button.
If you are still not convinced, maybe you can put your ear right onto my guitar amplifier, as I steadily increase the volume... see how far you can make it, before volume becomes a factor for you.
Again, you do not need a double blind fucking study for this kind of basic, common knowledge stuff.
@Michael Leigh Thanks for your relevant response in a thread that steered away from the original problem.
@gerhei If you go around with arguments like that we won't get any cure.
No. I think tinnitus caused by fusiform cells in the DCN going into overdrive and that boosts the signal through somatosensory neurons.When the tinnitus got higher in pitch and loudness, the disabling levels... any movement of my jaw would raise the pitch and loudness more. Chewing gum raised the loudness as well. I am considering that I have tensed up my middle ear and my neck when I was pushing on the muffs to increase any seal it had against my head.
Based on what? Sounds like nonsense.
I totally agree, I think you didn't read what I wrote. I was only talking about the principle ability to adapt, not about tinnitus loudness or distress caused by it. It is clear to me that the tinnitus distress in a tinnitus patient is higher when the loudness of the tinnitus is higher, I experienced that by myself some days ago during a cold.
Ok all good then.
Sorry if I misunderstood, but there actually are people out there, whom are making this claim.
They are evil in their obtuseness. Organizations like the ATA and BTA, because of their level of prominence and visibility, are actually our greatest enemies.
Which is probably false. Or likely to be false.I didn't write or tell that. I wrote the following:
"As far as I know there is no relation between the loudness of tinnitus and the ability to adapt to it, i.e. no matter how loud it is you can get used to it and your brain after some time starts to shift the signal out of your consciousness."
I think it's pretty clear what I mean. No matter how loud the tinnitus is, people should be able to adapt to it after some time. That the tinnitus is distressing in general and even more distressing when it is very loud is clear to me and I think to everyone else.
Which is probably false. Or likely to be false.
Yes x2. I already discussed all that before. Don't want to again.Maybe it is false, but a lot of researcher assume that this holds. Maybe there is discussion going on in academia I am not aware of since I didn't scan all publications and maybe it is also different among subgroups of tinnitus sufferers. Let's assume that it holds for the sake of argument. If it is true then it means for us that some sort of habituation is possible in the long term. I read "Tinnitus Retraining Therapy" from Jastreboff, which is the basis for a lot of subsequent research and the time that is assumed to be necessary to see some results is at least six months, in many cases 18 months - after a proper counseling and medical checks. If there was no counseling, no information by a doctor who is specialized in tinnitus and if the patient is still in the situation in which he feels that he has no power and is extremely negative towards the tinnitus, then the habituation hasn't even started. Things get more complicated when hyperacusis is involved because this conditions needs to be treated first.
May I ask you: Do you have hearing loss? Did the tinnitus appear due to an acoustic trauma?
It sure does, and that is why so many people have turned to medications to try and cope with their tinnitus, and I was one of them.Because loudness drives distress.